Specification2023 Yamaha F9.9SMHB2025 Tohatsu MFS9.8BS
ManufacturerYamahaTohatsu
ModelF9.9SMHBMFS9.8BS
Year20232025
Horsepower10 HP10 HP
Engine Type4-stroke4-stroke
Cylinders22
Displacement218 cc224 cc
Bore × Stroke51.8 × 51.8 mm54.6 × 47.9 mm
RPM Range5,100–5,900 RPM5,000–6,000 RPM
Fuel SystemEFIEFI
Fuel TypeRegularRegular
Weight42 kg (92 lbs)44 kg (96 lbs)
Starting SystemElectric/ManualElectric/Manual
SteeringBothBoth
Shaft LengthsS/LS
Gear Ratio2.08:12.00:1
Alternator10 A10 A
Trim & TiltManualManual
Prop Output6.41 kW6.49 kW
Recommended Boat10–15 ft10–15 ft
MSRP$2,940$2,730
Better / Advantage Lower / Disadvantage Equal / Neutral

2023 Yamaha F9.9SMHB vs 2025 Tohatsu MFS9.8BS — Which Is Better?

Choosing between the 2023 Yamaha F9.9SMHB and the 2025 Tohatsu MFS9.8BS comes down to your specific boating needs and priorities.

The 2023 Yamaha F9.9SMHB (2023) is a 10hp 4-stroke outboard from Yamaha, weighing 42 kg (92 lbs). Its electronic fuel injection delivers reliable starts and improved fuel economy compared to carbureted alternatives.

The 2025 Tohatsu MFS9.8BS offers 10hp with 4-stroke technology, tipping the scales at 44 kg (96 lbs). With a larger displacement of 224 cc, it can deliver more torque at lower RPMs.

Both motors are solid choices in the 9.9 HP class. Your final decision should factor in your boat size, typical use conditions, dealer availability in your area, and budget.